Re: CAROLE LOMBARD
Posted: August 17th, 2014, 7:31 pm
Hello everyone on this thread; I'm back from a long hiatus.
I'd like to add a note of dissention here -- while I certainly don't hate Lombard, I can't honestly say I'm wild about her either. It's really interesting how an actor can seem so different to different viewers. One of the things I've never liked about Lombard is that she simply doesn't reach me from the screen. I find her a not-warm screen presence; I don't really believe what she's doing, and I do, in fact, find her acting style pretty darn "drama school." I especially don't like the way she sort of sings her dialogue, in a fluty, musically descending, artificial style.
There are plenty of actors out there in old movies who have stagey, overdone, and/or artificial ways of delivering their lines. I dislike some because of it, and like others in spite of it. It's a matter of perception from the screen. Lombard has never moved me, but it's never been so bad that I've walked away. I've just said "meh."
I'd like to add a note of dissention here -- while I certainly don't hate Lombard, I can't honestly say I'm wild about her either. It's really interesting how an actor can seem so different to different viewers. One of the things I've never liked about Lombard is that she simply doesn't reach me from the screen. I find her a not-warm screen presence; I don't really believe what she's doing, and I do, in fact, find her acting style pretty darn "drama school." I especially don't like the way she sort of sings her dialogue, in a fluty, musically descending, artificial style.
There are plenty of actors out there in old movies who have stagey, overdone, and/or artificial ways of delivering their lines. I dislike some because of it, and like others in spite of it. It's a matter of perception from the screen. Lombard has never moved me, but it's never been so bad that I've walked away. I've just said "meh."