The Pale Blue Eye (2022)
Spoiler alert!
This thriller, which takes place at West Point in 1830, is on the cusp of horror. A cadet has been murdered — hanged — and his heart cut out. The military brass engage detective Augustus Landor (Christian Bale). Landor enlists the help of a young cadet — Edgar Allan Poe (Harry Melling) — who is interested in the case. Animals are discovered hanging from trees, with their hearts removed, and black magic is suspected. Another cadet is murdered, and his heart and genitals removed. West Point physician (Dr. Marquis, played by Toby Jones) is involved in the case. His family is strange. Landor consults a professor friend (Robert Duvall) who knows about witchcraft. Poe falls in love (too quickly) with Lea, Dr. Marquis’s daughter, who has a mysterious disease.
This is an odd film. Poe’s dead mother talks to him, in his sleep. Lea communicates with an ancestor who was involved in witchcraft. The climax (at least we think it’s the climax) is pure horror: Landor saves Poe just as the Marquis family, chanting in Latin, is about to cut his (Poe’s) heart out, in a ritual that is supposed to cure Lea of her disease. Landor drags Poe off that horror film table with the same urgency that we’ve seen distressed characters dragged off that table in so many movies. There’s a fire, and, as Landor escapes with Poe, also saving the bizarre Mrs. Marquis (Gillian Anderson), the flames engulf Lea and her brother Artemus.
But that’s not the end, because Poe has discovered all the facts, which are really quite tragic. It seems that the first murder was a sort of symbiotic situation: a vengeance killing, followed by “Well, the guy’s dead, we might as well cut out his heart and use it and the blood in our ritual.” The poor cow and sheep were red herrings.
Christian Bale is very good as the moody Landor, who has a lot on his mind. Harry Melling is good as Poe. I’ve seen him on stage three times and always enjoy his performances: in a Pinter play (
The Hothouse); as the lead in
Hand to God; and as Edgar in
King Lear.
This may not be a great movie, but I liked it, with its moodiness, collection of oddballs, heightened (some might say stilted) dialogue, and Dickensian-type characters played by an A-list cast. Btw Poe really was a cadet at West Point in 1830.
Bale and Melling as Landor and Poe
Gillian Anderson, Toby Jones: A very odd couple
Christian Bale, Robert Duvall